What is Affect Heuristic?

A video explaining Affect Heuristic by Rolf Dobelli the author of The Art of Thinking Clearly on the IDFC Mutual Fund Youtube Channel.

What is Affect Heuristic? And why you are a slave to your emotions

The affect heuristic is a mental shortcut used when making automatic decisions, whereby we rely heavily upon our emotional state during decision-making. Simply put – If you like something, you believe that the risks are smaller and the benefits greater than they actually are.

A rational approach to making decisions

What do you think of genetically modified wheat? It’s a complex issue. You don’t want to answer too hastily. A rational approach would be to consider the controversial technology’s pros and cons separately. Write down the possible benefits, weight them in terms of importance, and then multiply them by the probability that they will occur. Doing so, you get a list of expected values.

Next, do the same with the cons. List all the disadvantages, estimate their potential damage, and multiply them by the likelihood of them happening. The positive-sum minus the negative-sum equals the net expected value.

If it is above zero, you are in favour of genetically modified wheat. If the sum is below zero, you are against it. More than likely you have already heard of this approach. It is called ‘expected value’, and it features in most literature on decision theory. But just as probable is that you’ve never bothered to carry out such an evaluation. And without a doubt, none of the professors who wrote the textbooks turned to this method to select their spouses. 

But is the rational approach useful in everyday life?

Truth be told, no one uses this method to make decisions.

First of all, we lack enough imagination to list all the possible pros and cons. We are limited by what springs to mind; we can only conjure up what we have seen in our modest experience. It is hard to imagine a storm of the century if you’re only 30 years old.

Second, calculating small probabilities is impossible because we do not have enough data on rare events. The smaller the probability, the fewer data points we have and the higher the error rate on the exact probability – a vicious effect.

Third, our brain is not built for such calculations. They require time and effort – not our preferred state. In our evolutionary past, whoever thought too long and hard vanished inside a predator’s jaws. We are the descendants of quick decision-makers, and we rely on mental shortcuts called heuristics. One of the most popular is the affect heuristic

What is an ‘Affect’?

An affect is a momentary judgement: something you like or dislike. The word ‘gunfire’ triggers a negative effect. The word ‘luxury’ produces a positive one. This automatic, one-dimensional impulse prevents you from considering risks and benefits to be independent variables, which indeed they are. Instead, the affect heuristic puts risks and benefits on the same sensory thread.

Your emotional reactions to issues such as nuclear power, organic vegetables, private schools or motorbikes determine how you assess their risks and benefits. If you like something, you believe that the risks are smaller and the benefits greater than they actually are. If you don’t like something, the opposite is true. Risks and benefits appear to be dependent. Of course, in reality, they are not.

Even more impressive, suppose you own a Harley-Davidson. If you come across a study that states that driving one is riskier than previously thought, you will subconsciously tweak how you rate the benefits, deeming the experience ‘an even greater sense of freedom’.

But how does an affect – the initial, spontaneous emotion – come to be?

Researchers at the University of Michigan flashed either of three images for less than one-hundredth of a second in front of participants:

  • a smiling face,
  • an angry face,
  • or a neutral figure.

The subjects then had to indicate whether they liked a randomly selected Chinese character or not (the participants didn’t speak Chinese). Most preferred symbols that immediately followed the smiling face. Seemingly insignificant factors influence our emotions.

Here is another example where an insignificant factor plays a role

Researchers Hirschleifer and Shumway tested the relationship between the amount of morning sun and daily market performance in 26 major stock exchanges between 1982 and 1997. They found a correlation that reads much like a farmer’s adage:

“if the sun is shining in the morning, the stock market will rise during the day.”

Not always, but often. Who would have thought that sunshine could move billions? The morning sun obviously has the same effect as a smiley face. 

In conclusion

Whether we like it or not, we are puppets of our emotions. We make complex decisions by consulting our feelings, not our thoughts. Against our best intentions, we substitute the question, ‘What do I think about this?’ with ‘How do I feel about this?’ So, smile! Your future depends on it.

Next:
Introspection Illusion – BE YOUR OWN HERETIC

Similar Biases:
Association Bias – WHY EXPERIENCE CAN DAMAGE OUR JUDGEMENT
Loss Aversion – WHY EVIL STRIKES HARDER THAN GOOD
Salience Effect – HOW EYE-CATCHING DETAILS RENDER US BLIND
Contagion Bias – WOULD YOU WEAR HITLER’S SWEATER?

Previous:
Volunteer’s Folly – VOLUNTEER WORK IS FOR THE BIRDS

The above article is from the book The Art of Thinking Clearly by Rolf Dobelli. The article is only for educational and informative purposes to explain and understand cognitive biases. It is a great book, definitely worth a read!